Third-party vendors do not always push Amazon prices lower. When it comes to Fashion items, the e-tailer actually offers steeper discounts than third-party sellers, according to L2’s Amazon Fashion: Pricing report.

Driven by its price crawlers, which examine how much products cost on other sites, Amazon offers large discounts on expensive products. The average Amazon ASIN over $50 costs 7% less than the same product sold by third-party sellers. For products under $50, however, Amazon and third-party merchants generally offer comparable prices.

Amazon Fashion pricing

The case of Cole Haan illustrates that third-party sellers are not always the downward force in pricing. When it was first offered on Amazon in January 2014, the brand’s Pinch Buckle Slip-On Loafer cost $158. After inventory levels dropped two years later, Amazon lowered the price to $74.98 to clear remaining stock.

After Amazon sold through that stock, third-party merchants took over the listings. In only 12 days, the price had returned to $117.99. This suggests that third-party discounting can be a reaction to the pressure of Amazon’s pricing algorithm, and that if not forced to compete with Amazon’s discounting, sellers would return prices to natural levels.

Amazon Fashion Pricing

Sign up for L2’s daily newsletter.

L2's Daily Insights in Your Inbox.